From the creator of The Bachelor and The Bachelorette comes the ultimate collegiate wish fulfillment dating series. Fifteen of hottest co-eds on campus are chosen and must work together to find the hottest guy at the University and crown him the BIG MAN ON CAMPUS. In the first episode, the girls move into the house and bring six guys who to get to know better.

The girls and the BMOC throw a pool party that includes games of ""Bikini IQ,"" ""Tap Lap"" and ""Student Body ID."" Only the winner of ""Bikini IQ,"" Morgan, is lucky enough to win a one-on-one date with the BMOC. Kelly N. and Jessica C. win a massage date and Alex, Melissa and Jessica L. win a group pizza. The winner of a game of pool gets a first kiss with the BMOC. The next morning, the BMOC's friends arrive at the house to help him decide which 10 girls will be receiving pins and which five girls will be eliminated.

The party kicks off with the girls participating in a variety of activities including a contest where Alexandra wins a date with the BMOC. The chemistry heats up between the two during a romantic picnic by the campus fountain. Next, the BMOC surprises Jamie after class with a romantic stroll through the campus and for the third date, his friends organize a wild slumber party.

The girls are divided into teams of two and compete to win dates with BMOC by cleaning grimy police squad cars. Winners Michaela and Kat triumphantly each win a date with the BMOC. The BMOC takes Michaela to the UCF observatory for a night of romantic stargazing and treats Kat to home-cooked meal where the two talk about the future. Melissa is angry that she hasn't had a date alone with the BMOC but goes along with Jamie, Diamond and Alexandra to a tailgate party and game at the UCF Citrus Bowl where one of them unexpectedly shares a kiss with the BMOC that is flashed on the stadium's Jumbotron.

On the final day of competition, the girls' moms arrive to compete to win dates for their daughters. As a result, Michaela wins a spa date with Matt, while Alexandria and Matt take a romantic gondola ride. The remaining girls and Matt hit the batting cages and then a romantic dinner for three in center field where the true colors of Melissa and Kat come out. Finally, Matt makes the difficult decision abouty which two girls will not be receiving pins.

The final two girls, Michaela and Alexandria, are treated to romantic overnight dates with Matt. The first date with Michaela is in Cocoa Beach, where they talk about the possibilities of a future together. Later, Matt and Alexandra travel to St. Augustine, where they tour the quaint town and have a romantic dinner before returning to their room, which has been adorned with candles and rose petals. Upon returning to the house, all of the girls return and nervously await the pin ceremony that will reveals Matt's final choice.